BMW 1 Series vs Mercedes-Benz A-Class

BMW 1 Series or Mercedes-Benz A-Class? Price in Greece, power, space, safety and fuel use side by side, from KAR's car data. No brand pays to appear here.

  • The Mercedes-Benz A-Class costs less: from €39,900 against €41,900.
  • The Mercedes-Benz A-Class has more power: up to 306 hp against 300 hp.
  • The BMW 1 Series has the bigger boot: 380 L against 355 L.
  • The BMW 1 Series uses less fuel: from 5.5 against 6.0 L/100km.
  • KAR's data rates the BMW 1 Series as the more reliable of the two.

Side by side

BMW 1 Series and Mercedes-Benz A-Class: the figures side by side
BMW 1 SeriesMercedes-Benz A-Class
Price new€41,900 – €69,900€39,900 – €71,900Cheapest
Used prices€35,000 – €42,000€21,000 – €38,000
Power170–300 hp136–306 hpMost power
Boot380 LBiggest boot355 L
Rear seatsaverage roomaverage room
Seats55
Euro NCAPNo result in KAR's data yet5 stars, 2018
Fuel use5.5–7.6 L/100km6.0–8.0 L/100km
Energy use–17.0 kWh/100km
Electric range–75 km
Fuelpetrolpetrol, plug-in hybrid
Gearboxautomaticautomatic
Drivefront-wheel, all-wheelfront-wheel, all-wheel
Reliability (KAR's rating)goodaverage
Length4,361 mm4,419 mm
Kerb weight1,450 kg1,400 kg
On sale2024 to today2018 to today

Strengths and compromises

BMW 1 Series

Strengths

  • Sharp handling and a modern cabin
  • M135 is a fast all-weather hot hatch

Compromises

  • Firm ride on sport suspension

Mercedes-Benz A-Class

Strengths

  • Upmarket cabin with twin wide screens
  • Plug-in A 250 e for electric city driving

Compromises

  • Small boot and firm ride on big wheels

More comparisons

Figures from KAR's car data, checked October 2026. Prices are typical ranges for Greece: confirm them with the seller before you buy. All comparisons